Taking the Critical Path Towards Succession

In our Succession Planning Starter Kit, we lay out all the steps to build a solid business transition plan in 210 days.

  • Assessment – 90 days
  • Execution – 90 days
  • Communication – 30 days

Once we can get a business owner past the procrastination or constraints of time and inertia, the Assessment phase can flow fairly smoothly with an estimation of business value, a discussion about the owner’s post-transition plans and goals, and two potential options for future owners or successors. (We discuss why you should have a plan A and a plan B in the starter kit.)

The second phase, execution, is where many new gaps or “constraints” arise. These constraints can include the following:

  • Wills need updating based upon new tax laws
  • No non-compete agreements with some of your key management
  • Disability policy is woefully inadequate based on the level of income needed
  • Personal investment portfolio is performing below average (e.g. 1 percent rate of return when it needs to be at least 5 percent)
  • Legal entity structure changes needed to pay less tax upon sale
  • Unaddressed estate tax problem

Business owners can get lost in one of these constraints, impeding the transition planning process. Instead, the supply chain Theory of Constraints advises taking the critical path. This means starting with the constraint that will take the longest to sort out. We advise going through the entire business transition planning process first, and then you’ll be crystal clear about the largest constraint to achieving your goal.

Working with your CPA, attorney and other advisors, you can prioritize these constraints and take the critical path forward. As each constraint is “broken,” you move on to the next largest and most complex constraint. Before you know it, your priorities are ticked off and you are that much closer to achieving the net worth outcome from your business that you deserve.

Why leave your future to chance or someone else’s control? Supply chain management is a proven methodology for increasing throughput, reducing operational expenses and investment — thereby improving profits. In this competitive environment, you owe it to yourself and your key employees, maybe even to your country, to plan for a successful transition of your business. Identify your constraints, and if the main constraint is you, it’s time to get out of your own way and plan for success.

Download the Whitepaper: How Supply Chain Theory Applies to Your Business Transition Plan

Gary Jackson, CPA, is a tax partner at Cornwell Jackson. Gary has built businesses, managed them, developed leadership teams and sold divisions of his business, and he utilizes this real world practical experience at Cornwell Jackson and in providing tax planning to individuals and business leaders across North Texas.

Contact him at gary.jackson@cornwelljackson.com.

Protect Your Company from Immigration Infractions


More than three decades have elapsed since the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) began requiring employers to complete I-9 forms when hiring to verify a new employee’s identity and authorization to work in the United States. Given the recent focus on illegal immigration, there’s a good chance that immigration enforcement efforts at the employer  level might be stepped up.

As with the IRS in the tax arena, the prospect of an audit by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency is intended to ensure that employers toe the line. That’s why the financial cost of violating the IRCA can be severe, depending on the nature of the infraction.

Determination of Penalties

The steepest penalties — up to $16,000 per violation — are levied against employers that knowingly hire and keep undocumented workers on the payroll.

More typical are penalties of up to $1,100 per violation for failing to satisfy the law’s administrative requirements. Chances are that if you have I-9 recordkeeping issues with one employee, you’ll have them with many, which means that the $1,100 per violation maximum penalty can quickly add up.

When deciding how big of a penalty to assess, ICE will take into consideration the following factors:

  • The size of the organization,
  • ICE’s assessment of its “good faith effort to comply” with the law,
  • The seriousness of the violation,
  • Whether the violation involves unauthorized workers, and
  • Any history of previous violations.

Remember that IRCA requires you to keep I-9s on file for not only current employees, but also former employees — for at least three years from the date of hire, or one year after the employee has left you, whichever is longer.

Proactive Steps

If you receive a notice of inspection from ICE, you will have three days to produce all your I-9s on file (extensions are sometimes granted, but you shouldn’t count on it). Be sure to make copies of forms before you provide the originals to ICE. Typically ICE will also ask for supporting documentation, such as a copy of your payroll and employee roster, business permits and articles of incorporation.

There are steps you can take immediately after being informed that you will be inspected (that is, you’re presented with a notice of inspection) that might nip any issues in the bud. As soon as a notice is received, check your I-9 files for any potential problems. You can try to fill in any missing data items on those forms. It’s up to ICE whether to absolve you based on any post-notice corrections.

However, if you failed to obtain I-9s at the time of hiring, what you can’t do is round up documentation from employees and fill out the forms after you have received the notice. ICE can use forensics experts to determine whether you have done so, and such a discovery would compound your problems.

Possible ICE Responses

Following an audit (which could take months or even years), you will receive a response from ICE, which typically will fall into one of the following categories:

Notice of inspection results. Also known as a “compliance letter,” this is used to notify you that your company was found to be in compliance.

Notice of suspect documents. This tells you that, based on a review of the I-9s and documentation submitted by the employee, ICE has determined that an employee is not authorized to work and advises you of the possible criminal and civil penalties for continuing to employ that individual. ICE will give you and the employee an opportunity to present additional documentation to rebut this conclusion.

Notice of discrepancies. A discrepancy notice tells you that, based on its review of the I-9s and documentation submitted by an employee, ICE has been unable to determine that individual’s work eligibility. You will need to give the employee a copy of the notice and explain that this is an opportunity to provide ICE with more evidence of his or her legal status.

Notice of technical or procedural failures. This notice lists technical violations identified during the inspection and gives your company 10 business days to correct them. After those 10 days, uncorrected technical and procedural failures will become substantive violations.

Warning notice. This is issued when ICE has found substantive verification violations, but circumstances don’t warrant a monetary penalty and ICE is confident you will comply going forward.

Notice of intent to fine (NIF). This is the worst-case scenario. It means ICE has found what it considers to be “substantive, uncorrected technical, knowingly hire and continuing to employ violations.”

In the unlikely event that your company does receive an NIF, it’s not a done deal. You can either negotiate a settlement with ICE or, according to the agency, ask for a hearing before the Office of the Chief Administrative Hearing Officer within 30 days.

High Stakes

What happens after you hear back from ICE will, of course, depend on what they find. As noted, you might need to ask some employees to account for any problems ICE uncovers, such as a lack of evidence that an employee has legal authority to work in the U.S. If such an employee fails to respond, you will be obliged to terminate that person.

Given the high stakes, if you receive a notice of inspection, it’s advisable to consult with legal counsel having expertise in ICE matters.

What’s the best thing to do when you receive a large inheritance?

BY AMY KOTHMANN

Our friends at Richard P. Slaughter Associates, Inc. recently published an article in Worth Magazine that answers the question What’s the best thing to do when you receive a large inheritance? To read the full article, click here.

Trillions of dollars are now changing hands as older parents transfer their significant wealth to baby boomer children. Ideally, that older generation’s estate planning has protected assets and ensured a smooth handover. Now, however, as a beneficiary, it is your responsibility to ensure this familial wealth is maintained. The decisions you make following an inheritance will directly impact how that wealth is preserved for you and future generations.

Here are five issues to consider to ensure the desired outcome:

1. DON’T MAKE IMMEDIATE CHANGES.

Fight the urge to make immediate large purchases with the funds. Rash decisions can be costly and difficult to remedy. Also realize that receiving an inheritance can be an emotional time, likely linked to the loss of a close loved one. Give yourself time to process the change and create a strategy before making any big spending decisions.

2. SEEK PROFESSIONAL ADVICE.

A large inheritance changes your overall wealth picture, affecting your household budget, investment tactics, tax implications and risk-management needs. Find an advisor who has the credentials and expertise in serving these needs, to help map the appropriate strategies for your new wealth level. This should include coordination across your team of professionals: your CPA, attorney, insurance specialist and, of course, your wealth-management advisor.

3. PROPERLY TITLE ASSETS.

Be wary of consolidating inherited assets into existing accounts merely for the sake of simplicity. Draining a trust or commingling inherited funds into jointly titled accounts can cause the funds to lose their separate property character. This would give a spouse (and his or her beneficiaries) potential claim to a portion of those assets in the event of death or divorce, negating the protection mechanisms your predecessors worked hard to create.

4. CONSIDER TAXES.

Taxation concerns don’t cease once the estate has been settled. Revisiting your personal tax outlook after an inheritance is essential to ensure you are maximizing both your current and long-term trajectory. This is particularly true when the bulk of an inheritance is in retirement accounts from a nonspouse. In this case , you will be required to take minimum withdrawals from the accounts that are taxable as ordinary income. This could cause unintended tax consequences, especially if you are still working and earning wages; those consequences, however, can be mitigated by using other income-deferral strategies. Conversely, beneficiaries already in retirement may benefit from realizing more than the minimum of the inherited monies now, either through withdrawals or Roth conversions. This could smooth out their tax bills down the road when their own minimum distributions begin. All in all, carefully planned timing of how and when your income is realized can lead to significant tax savings; so any plan you already have needs to be revised to include your inherited funds.

5. PLAN YOUR OWN LEGACY.

Reevaluation of your own legacy is crucial. This includes such actions as updating estate-planning documents to incorporate the newly inherited assets. You also should reassess your wealth-transfer goals and strategies to ensure the most appropriate tools are utilized for your new wealth level. Mechanisms that were appropriate prior to the inheritance might no longer be your best option, depending on your goals and outlook. This is particularly important when an inheritance puts you near the lifetime estate-tax exclusion, as tax-efficient strategies such as lifetime gifting can be a powerful way to transfer wealth tax-free. Once your plans are established, communicating them to heirs is critical, to ensure your efforts are not in vain. Your wealth manager can help educate future heirs on the skills necessary to manage their future wealth to ensure the family wealth is preserved across generations.

RICHARD P. SLAUGHTER ASSOCIATES IS A LEADING WEALTH-MANAGEMENT FIRM, SPECIALIZING IN DELIVERING TAILORED STRATEGIES AS A FIDUCIARY AND ADVOCATE FOR HIGH NET WORTH INDIVIDUALS, FAMILIES AND BUSINESSES.

Slaughter Associates constructs wealth-management strategies around a financial plan, providing active, diversified and conservative asset management through internal experts. These experts establish a collaborative relationship with clients and all their financial service professionals, helping clients navigate the financial complexities that high net worth individuals and families face. Founded in 1991 in Austin, Texas, by Richard P. Slaughter, Slaughter Associates is one of the original fee-based firms in the nation. Through its subsidiary, RPS Retirement Plan Advisors, Slaughter Associates works with corporate clients by providing 3(38) fiduciary services, which help mitigate risk for plan sponsors and secure retirement readiness for employees. With offices in both Austin and the Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex, Slaughter Associates has been recognized by the National Association of Board Certified Advisory Practices as a Premier Advisor and has been awarded Exemplary status for expertise in personal risk management.

When Rolling Over Can Be the Wrong Strategy

When you retire or change jobs, it is generally a good idea to roll over your employer-sponsored qualified retirement plan balances into a traditional IRA.

But that advice may change if the employer-qualified plan account holds appreciatedcompany stock. In that case, you could be better off withdrawing the shares, paying the taxes, and holding the stock in a taxable brokerage firm account. Here is why.That way, you avoid an immediate tax hit and continue to benefit from tax-deferred earnings growth until you withdraw money from the IRA.

An Example to Show the Mechanics of the Strategy

Let’s say you retire from your job at age 60. As part of a lump-sum distribution from your company-sponsored, qualified retirement plan, you receive 2,000 shares of employer stock. The shares have a cost basis to the plan of $10,000 and a current market value of $80,000.

You expect the stock to continue to appreciate, so you don’t plan to sell in the near future. Instead of rolling the shares into an IRA, you deposit them in a taxable brokerage house account. You then pay tax at your ordinary rate of, say 25%, on the $10,000 cost basis amount. So the federal income tax hit is $2,500 (25% of $10,000). Since you are older than age 55, you don’t owe the 10% premature withdrawal penalty tax.

Your tax basis in the shares is now $10,000. You can roll over some or all of any other money received in your lump-sum distribution tax-free into a traditional IRA.

Years later, you die after the employer shares have appreciated to $180,000. Your heirs will receive a federal income tax basis step-up equal to the post-distribution appreciation in value ($100,000 in this example).

When your heirs sell the stock, they will owe capital gains tax on the $70,000 worth of net unrealized appreciation ($80,000 market value as of the plan distribution date minus the $10,000 cost basis in the shares). Assuming a 15% capital gains rate, the total federal income tax hit on the $180,000 worth of stock is only $13,000:

  • $2,500 paid by you when you received the shares as part of the lump-sum distribution.
  • $10,500 (15% of the $70,000 of net unrealized appreciation) paid by your heirs when the shares are finally sold.
  • That amounts to an effective federal income tax rate of only 7.22%.
  • In contrast, if you had rolled the employer shares over into an IRA, your heirs would eventually owe tax at ordinary income rates on the entire $180,000. In all likelihood, the resulting federal income tax hit would be at least 25%, or $45,000.

Tax Deferral

The net unrealized appreciation of the shares goes untaxed until you sell them. As long as the shares are part of a lump-sum distribution from your retirement accounts, you pay current tax only on the retirement plan’s cost basis in the stock. The cost basis is generally the value of the shares when they were acquired by the plan. The net unrealized appreciation is the difference between cost basis to the plan and the shares’ market value on the date they are distributed to you.

If the shares have appreciated substantially, the plan’s cost basis could be a relatively small percentage of the shares current market value as of the distribution date. However, the cost basis could still be significant in absolute dollars, so the tax hit may be more than a nominal amount.

In addition, if you are under 55 years of age when you leave your job, you generally have to pay the 10 percent federal tax penalty on premature withdrawals. That might be worth it, though, if the taxable income, which is equal to the cost basis, is small.

Tax Savings

When the net unrealized appreciation is taxed, it automatically qualifies as a long-term capital gain eligible for favorable capital gains rates (see IRS Notice 98-24). As you know, the current maximum federal rate on long-term capital gains is only 20%, compared with a maximum 39.6% on ordinary income.

Additional Tax Savings

Appreciation of the shares after the distribution also qualifies for the favorable capital gains rates, provided you hold the stock for more than 12 months after receiving them from the plan.

Even More Tax Savings

If you own the stock when you die, your heirs are entitled to a federal income tax basis step-up for any post-distribution appreciation. However, when they sell the shares, the net unrealized appreciation will be taxed under the “income in respect of a decedent” rules. The good news is the unrealized appreciation will be taxed at the favorable rates for long-term capital gains. (see IRS Revenue Ruling 75-125)

In contrast, if you roll the employer stock over tax free into an IRA, you pay tax on the stock gains only when the shares are sold and you take withdrawals from the IRA. The net unrealized appreciation and post-distribution appreciation will count as ordinary income, so you or your heirs will owe as much as 39.6% in taxes rather than the favorable capital gains tax. (See right-hand box.)

Before following this tax-saving strategy, be sure the shares qualify and are part of a lump-sum distribution. The rules are tricky, so consult with your tax adviser if you have questions or want to discuss whether this maneuver will work for you.

Franchisor Enters Agreement to Help Franchisees Comply with Labor Laws

Sonic Industries Services, Inc, franchisor of the SONIC drive-through restaurant chain, has entered into a voluntary agreement with the U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) Wage and Hour Division (WHD) to help its independently owned and operated franchise locations comply with the federal labor laws.

 

SONIC Drive-In restaurants are the nation’s largest drive-in chain, serving approximately 3 million customers daily. Nearly 94% of its 3,500 drive-in locations are locally owned and operated. SONIC has been the subject of several wage theft lawsuits that involved workers alleging that they didn’t receive overtime after working 40 hours in a week and were required to work “off the clock.”

As part of the agreement, SONIC will provide a forum and the resources needed to assist the WHD in educating its drive-in owners, managers, and employees nationwide.

Fair Labor Standards Act

The FLSA requires that covered, nonexempt  employees be paid at least the federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour as well as time and one half their regular rates for every hour they work beyond 40 per week. It also requires employers to maintain accurate records of their employees’ wages, hours and other conditions of employment.

The WHD will provide compliance assistance tools designed for the franchise restaurant industry. The package will include video and online training, educational articles for use in internal company publications, and sample training materials for use in company staff meetings. The WHD will also make representatives available to provide training and compliance assistance to SONIC franchisees. In addition, the WHD and SONIC will collaborate using publicly available data to promote franchisee compliance with the Fair Labor Standards Act.

The agreement states that it is not “an admission” by SONIC that it “is a joint employer of the workers employed by its franchisees. WHD recognizes that the existence of a franchise relationship, in and of itself, does not create joint employment.”

The SONIC agreement is similar to an agreement that the WHD entered into with the Subway restaurant chain in 2016.

WHD Deputy Administrator for Program Operations, Patricia Davidson, noted that the WHD will “encourage other franchisors to follow SONIC’s example and take similar steps to benefit their franchises’ employees and owners by complying with the law.” She believes that complying with the wage and hour laws makes good business sense, rather than paying back wages, damages, and penalties for violations.

Utilize Data Collected on the Shop Floor

Idle machines, production bottlenecks, equipment breakdowns, absent employees, new orders — these are just some of the factors that can disrupt production and eat into your company’s profit.

Could you improve control, workflow and decision-making abilities if you had real-time tracking of work in progress? One software solution that’s starting to gain acceptance is the shop floor control system, otherwise known as the manufacturing execution system (MES). It enables planning and real-time tracking either as a stand-alone system or integrated with an enterprise resource planning system.

The manufacturing execution system provides information about activities from orders to finished goods. It is particularly useful for managing operations that run small batches and process numerous varied orders, such as those typical of pharmaceutical, computer chip and chemical product manufacturers. It involves four major stages:

1. Planning begins with the customer order. Process times and materials are determined, and the due date and truck loading date are entered into the program.

2. Scheduling is set up according to how the new order fits into work already in production. The system sees the forest, as well as the trees, so that process sequencing of all orders utilizes each machine or workstation to its advantage. Schedules can be printed and posted. Workstations aren’t totally locked into the schedule.

For example, if there are two identical machines scheduled to divide one job equally, the supervisor might see that one machine and operator could do 60 percent of the order, which would allow the other machine operator time to cross-train another employee. The MES program also provides specifications, instructions and drawings for the job, and computer numerical control machine operators can download “recipes” for running their machines.

3. Tracking is handled in real-time and displayed on computer monitors. The system identifies and tracks components by reading bar-coded labels or travelers. When a problem occurs, such as a delay in getting materials, the schedule can be updated and the changes communicated to every workstation.

4. Reporting and documenting work in progress lets everyone know if processes and the orders themselves are completed as scheduled. As an order moves through production, each workstation makes an entry into the system upon the completion of its work and explains any deviation from work as scheduled.

On one level, the cost savings realized by using a manufacturing execution system are derived simply from greater efficiencies in the day-to-day utilization of equipment and labor. On another level, MES reports provide valuable data that can aid a company’s decision-making ability. They amass important information such as processing history, time on line, time in queue and rejection rate.

Note: Once you get MES reports, be sure to use them. One study found that many companies miss the boat by failing to train managers to use the information available to them.

Business ID Theft: Is Your Data at Risk?

The IRS and state tax authorities have made significant strides in curbing individual identity theft over the last two years.

IRS Focuses on Preventing Business ID Theft

“The IRS, state tax agencies and the tax community have worked hard to turn the tide against tax-related identity theft. We’re making progress in protecting individuals but we still have more work to do,” said IRS Commissioner John Koskinen in a recent press release.

Trends in ID Theft

But cyber attacks against businesses are on the upswing. Here are some simple ways business taxpayers can help protect their data from hackers.

The IRS recently announced that the number of individuals reporting identity theft in the first half of 2017 has declined dramatically compared to 2015 and 2016. For the first five months of 2017, about 107,000 individual taxpayers reported stolen IDs. In comparison, 297,000 victims filed reports during the same time period in 2015 and 204,000 in 2016.

Put simply, individual ID theft dropped 47% over the last year. The IRS attributes the decrease to safeguards put in place during the 2016 Security Summit.

Unfortunately, the IRS has also noted an increase in ID theft involving business tax returns. While the number of businesses affected was relatively low, the potential dollar amounts were significant:

Year Estimated business ID theft cases through June 1 Estimated losses
2015 350 tax returns $122 million
2016 4,000 tax returns $268 million
2017 10,000 tax returns $137 million

The victims of business ID theft include corporations, estates and trusts, and partnerships. These days, hackers are bolder and increasingly tax savvy in their scams. For example, they may use stolen data to file bogus business tax returns and then collect refunds. Or they might post the stolen data for resale on the so-called “Dark Net” so other criminals can file fraudulent tax returns.

Tax professionals have been helping clients take appropriate security measures to prevent business ID theft, but problems persist. “We need help from the tax community to combat cybercriminals and raise security awareness,” IRS Commissioner John Koskinen noted.

Ways to Combat Business ID Theft

Because business ID theft can be so costly, prevention and early detection measures are critical. Here are some simple, but effective, security measures you should consider:

Make cybersecurity a top priority.

Similar to an annual business plan, your company needs a formal cybersecurity plan that identifies a step-by-step approach for detecting ID theft. When breaches happen, your plan should trigger a prompt, thorough response.

Safeguard intellectual property.

Companies should store all employee and customer data, along with other proprietary records, such as financial statements and prior years’ tax returns, in a safe location. Shred nonessential documents before throwing them out, and limit access to your employer ID number to parties with whom you initiated the contact. Share sensitive information via the Internet or email only if the recipient is trusted (such as your lender or tax preparer) and the site is secure.

Use the latest cybersecurity technology.

This includes firewalls, antivirus and antimalware software, and spam filters. Also exercise common sense: Don’t download files, click on links, or open pop-ups or attachments sent from unknown sources. Stored files should be encrypted for your protection and for the benefit of customers.

Educate employees.

Conduct periodic training sessions to remind employees about the latest scams, such as phishing emails where hackers pose as familiar businesses or colleagues to steal sensitive information. They should also be aware of your cybersecurity plan and each person’s role if a breach occurs.

Use prepaid credit cards for purchases.

Prepaid employee credit cards limit your potential for losses when employees make purchases from suppliers and vendors. If a card is breached, the company can lose only what’s prepaid and you can immediately deactivate the card.

Monitor business credit reports.

It doesn’t take much effort to monitor your company’s profiles from the three major business credit bureaus: Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. Subscribe to their monitoring services for round-the-clock access. What’s more, you can choose to receive real-time email notifications about suspicious activities affecting your company’s credit rating.

Guard your master list.

Some companies track all their accounts and passwords in a master list, which can be convenient, but dangerous. A dishonest employee or hacker who manages to gain access to that list has the key to all your company’s information in one fell swoop, so you’ll need to be extra cautious with security measures.

Finally, contact your tax professional promptly if you believe you’ve been victimized. He or she can help you get in touch with the appropriate law enforcement authorities, business credit bureaus and financial institutions.

No Guarantees

No preventive measure is 100% fail safe. The IRS and tax preparers are expanding their efforts to educate businesses and prevent breaches. You can also help lower your risk by crafting a formal cybersecurity plan, educating employees and implementing various other proactive security measures.

Which Employees or Positions Do You Rely on Most?

It’s standard operating procedure for marketers to segment customers according to their value to the organization, to ensure that those who are most vital to the growth and profitability of a company are well-cared-for and don’t disappear. The same needs to be done with regard to employees. Appearances can be deceiving.

For example, your largest customer measured by dollars generated could also be among your least profitable, if that customer consumes an inordinate amount of your time and other resources. In the same way, some employees at the high end of your compensation scale might not be nearly as valuable to you as some on the lower end. Higher-paying positions might have more to do with labor market traditions and preconceived assumptions about certain roles within a company than the actual value added to a company’s operations. In some businesses, the greatest draw for customers might be a friendly and knowledgeable receptionist, though he or she is likely to be among the lowest paid on staff.

Suppose, in your labor market, network IT professionals command a good salary. Your business needs an IT professional, so you pay the market price to recruit and keep one on board. But if you’re assuming that that employee is more vital to your success than an exceptional customer service representative simply because the former earns twice as much as the latter, you could be wrong.

Skills Quadrant Model

One insightful framework for taking a fresh look at your workforce, known as the Lepak & Snell model, is a four-quadrant, skills-based paradigm dividing employees by value of particular skills to your organization and the skills’ uniqueness in the labor market. The visual result is a box with the following four quadrants.

High skill value, high skill uniqueness: these employees are considered the “criticals.” High skill value, low skill uniqueness, these employees are the “professionals,” skilled and semi-skilled.
High skill uniqueness, low skill value: these employees are the “specialists.” Low skill value, low skill uniqueness: these employees are the “doers.”

You’ll probably assess your employees’ skills on the value spectrum based on criteria such as the ability to lower costs, increase revenue, strengthen customer relationships, foster team collaboration, offer creative ideas and solve problems.

The uniqueness-of-skills spectrum depicts the degree to which employees’ skills are narrowly applicable to your organization, and, thus, harder to find in the labor market. Let’s say you produce a unique, expensive and complex product. It takes years for employees involved in the production to develop the necessary talent. Those employees will be rated highly on the skill spectrum. The same principle is applicable to specialized services.

The purpose of the framework isn’t solely to categorize your current employees, but also to help you organize your workforce structure by job function. You can create a generic organizational chart by department or by division and assign job titles and functions to the four quadrants. For example, a sales manager position might require an employee who qualifies as a critical employee. Chances are you’ll need employees representing all four quadrants in most if not all departments.

After you’ve completed your generic organization chart, compare it to your actual one and analyze the inconsistencies: Are some departments understaffed in terms of skill? Overstaffed? If so, why? Is any action warranted, either in the short-term or over a longer period of time? What would be the operational consequence of having to fill vacancies in any of those positions?

Identify the Criticals

As previously noted, employees whose skills combine high value and uniqueness are known as the “criticals,” that is, critical to your success. Putting those criticals at the top of your retention priority list makes sense, though there are no guarantees that you can keep them on board in spite of your best efforts. Even if a competitor doesn’t lure these employees away, today’s society is increasingly mobile and people move away or seek new challenges or retire.

That’s why you need to think carefully about your talent pipeline and succession planning, so that when critical employees leave, you don’t want to be left in the lurch.

Employees who don’t fall into the “critical” quadrant, assuming they satisfy your performance criteria, can’t be taken for granted. Just because an employee isn’t critical doesn’t mean you would welcome the burden of finding a replacement. But by using this talent quadrant lens, you have a clearer view of how to prioritize your efforts to keep employees engaged and content with their jobs.

Finally, keep in mind that maximizing employee engagement and satisfaction — whether it be that of a critical employee, professional, specialist, or other — often requires a tailored approach, as opposed to one-size-fits-all. For example, emphasizing tangible forms of compensation could cause you to lose some of your criticals who find motivation in other ways.

The Lepak & Snell model isn’t the “be all and end all” of understanding your workforce. If it doesn’t seem applicable to your organization, find one that will allow you to consider other ways of looking at how effectively you’re leveraging your organization’s substantial investment in “human capital.” Expect to find a few surprises if you do.

Put Social Networking Sites to Work for Your Dealership

If you’re thinking that social media is just for teenagers, think again. More than half of those logging on to social media sites are in their mid-thirties or older.

Traditional media outlets such as newspapers, radio, and television have long served the purpose of delivering one-way messages, like your dealership’s advertising.

Social media, by contrast, uses Web-based platforms to not only deliver your message, but to allow the recipient to participate.

You’ll find a number of technologies under the umbrella of social media, including e-mail, instant messaging, blogs and social networking websites.

In fact, sites like Facebook and Twitter have now surpassed traditional search engines when it comes to reaching new car prospects, according to J.D. Power and Associates.

The end result? Social media is not only changing the way your customers access news and information, but how they do business. If your dealership has not yet embraced the power of social media, it might be time to take another look.

What Radio Station Do You Drive?

Brandcasting is what manufacturers, including some auto dealers, are doing to promote their products in a way that is less intrusive and more inviting. Rather than employing the traditional media to do “push” marketing, they are using social media to “pull” the audience in. How? By cleverly linking the public’s passion for cars with their passion for music through a dealership-provided “radio station.”

The radio station is brand-specific and is linked from the dealer’s website. The public can access the station 24/7 on their computers or smart phones, and play the music in the background while they migrate to other sites or answer e-mail. If a listener should happen to visit the actual brick-and-mortar dealership, he or she would likely hear the same station playing in the showroom or as the “on hold” music during a phone call.

The idea, of course, is to marry the listener’s love for cars to the dealer’s brand. Towards that goal, the music is embedded with subtle messages that promote the dealership’s new and used cars as well as its service specials. Think of it this way: the music is the precious cargo, and the marketing messages are the Styrofoam packing peanuts that fill in the empty spaces along the journey.

It’s a clever idea that goes straight to the heart of selling… using shared interest to turn a prospect into a friend.


Two Success Stories

If branding, communication and targeted marketing efforts are not compelling enough, consider the following social networking success stories:

Texas Dealer, Domestic Automobiles. A dealership in Texas recently launched into the realm of social networking. To get the ball rolling, the dealer decided to tie its social networking initiative into a fundraiser for Haiti relief. For every fan added during a specified time frame, a dollar was donated to the Haiti relief effort. To further sweeten the transaction, the dealership’s corporate offices jumped on board and matched the dealership’s pledge.

Employees spread the word about this fundraiser through posts on their own social networking sites. And, in just over a week, the dealership added several hundred fans. These additions not only translated into several thousands of dollars donated to Haiti relief, but, the fundraising and fan-raising effort garnered a significant amount of publicity for the dealership as well as an online following.

Minnesota Dealer, Foreign Automobiles.Interested in entering the social networking realm, but concerned about the time commitment, one Minnesota dealer adopted software made expressly for dealers interested in expanding their social networking ventures. Within days, the dealership boasted a number of accounts, including one on Facebook. In addition to establishing a presence, the software integrated with the dealership’s dealer management system, which allowed for their inventory to be displayed directly on their Facebook page.

The dealer added more than 150 fans during the first week and received recognition from a number of traditional media sources. The dealer now averages 35 client and prospect interactions per week as a result of this social networking initiative.

Social Networking Websites

Separate from our professional lives, many of us have a profile on at least one social networking website. That’s why many businesses, large and small, are employing this innovative new marketing tool. Automobile dealerships are no exception.

Adopting these technologies, however, involves more than creating a profile or fan page for your dealership. To really be effective, it requires a shift to a culture of transparency. And, it is this window into your dealership that makes it more important than ever for your message to be consistent at every point of contact with current and prospective customers.

How Social Media Puts You Out Front

Establishing a presence on social networking sites can give your dealership a competitive edge in several ways, including:

1. Brand Enhancement.

Profiles, fan pages and participation in groups all serve to build awareness about your dealership’s brand. They also provide an opportunity to interact with current customers as well as begin the relationship-building process with prospective ones.

2. Open Communication.

Social media, including social networking, is based on the principle of two-way communication.

Your dealership can benefit from both the positive experiences and negative feedback that customers voluntarily share. Not only can you address these customer concerns publicly, but you then have the chance to make any necessary improvements. You have the unique opportunity to make lemonade out of lemons.

3. Target Marketing.

Establishing a presence on social networking sites can help you identify, and subsequently target, potential customers. While the need for advertising through traditional media outlets may not be eliminated, the ability to target marketing communications reduces overall costs and provides a greater return on your marketing investment.

Tapping into social networking analysis tools may also assist with targeted marketing efforts. What if, for example, you knew that online discussions about trucks and SUVs waned during the prior 12-month period, while conversations about fuel efficiency, including hybrids, increased significantly?

Now there is some market intelligence to take under advisement when developing your marketing message. It is important, however, to keep in mind that overt advertising on social networking sites can be received negatively, so your message should be developed with that caution.

Social Networking Best Practices

Whether you are new to social networking, or a seasoned veteran, it’s important to:

Make a Commitment.

Social networking, like most marketing tools, requires a commitment to time and possibly finances — perhaps even cultural change within your dealership — in exchange for successful results.

Be Visible.

Make sure that your brand remains consistent between the various social networking sites. Develop a communications plan that keeps your dealership visible, but that does not overwhelm your online following.

Listen First, Respond Second.

Once your program is established, monitor the social buzz daily to keep a pulse on both current and potential customers. Much like a dinner party, you must listen before you respond. Then, once you have a clear picture of what is being said online, you can determine a course of action.

Keep it Local.

Customers and prospective customers alike want to do business with dealerships that are within driving distance. Keep this in mind as you develop and refine your social networking plan.

Make it Easy.

Remember to make it simple for people to find you. Add social networking information to business cards as well as your dealership’s Web site.

If your dealership hasn’t yet gotten its feet wet in the world of social networking, it may be time to rethink your marketing strategy. Establishing a presence on social networking sites can be particularly effective when it comes to heightened brand awareness for your dealership and for identification and targeting of potential customers. In addition, finding ways to tie social networking initiatives into community efforts can create a win-win situation for everyone involved.

Beware of a 100% Personal Liability Penalty

A “100% penalty” can be assessed against a responsible person when federal income tax and/or federal employment taxes are withheld from employee paychecks but aren’t handed over to the government.

This Trust Fund Recovery Penalty got its informal “100% penalty” moniker from the fact that the entire unpaid amount can be assessed against a responsible person (or several responsible persons). The purpose of the penalty is to collect withheld but unpaid federal taxes from individuals who had control over an employer’s finances.

Often, operating a business as a corporation protects the individual owner from personal liability for some corporate debts. In cases of unpaid payroll taxes, however, the corporate shield or corporate veil is “pierced” and the IRS looks past the corporation to the responsible person to pay the debt.

Determining Who’s Responsible

The 100% penalty can only be assessed against a responsible person. That could be a shareholder, director, officer or employee of a corporation; a partner or employee of a partnership; or a member (owner) or employee of a multi-member LLC. It can also be assessed against an employee of a sole proprietorship or an employee of a single-member (one owner) LLC. To be hit with the penalty, the individual must:

  1. Be responsible for collecting, accounting for, and paying withheld federal taxes, and
  2. Willfully fail to remit those taxes (willful means intentional, deliberate, voluntary and knowing, as opposed to accidental).

The mere authority to sign checks when directed to do so by a superior doesn’t make a person responsible. There must also be knowledge of and control over the finances of the business. However, responsible person status can’t be deflected simply by assigning signature authority over bank accounts to another person in order to avoid the 100% penalty. As a practical matter, the IRS will look first and hard at individuals with check-signing authority.

The courts have examined several factors beyond the authority to sign checks when they determined who had responsible person status. Those factors include whether the individual:

  • Is an officer or director,
  • Owns shares or has an entrepreneurial stake in the company,
  • Is active in managing the day-to-day affairs of the company,
  • Can hire and fire employees,
  • Makes decisions regarding which, when, and in what order debts or taxes will be paid, and
  • Exercises daily control over bank accounts and disbursement records.

Outside Parties Can Be Responsible

In certain circumstances, outside parties such as lenders and advisors can also be responsible persons. For example:

  1. A bank had the authority under a loan agreement with a delinquent corporation to oversee much of the corporation’s operations. It exercised this authority by honoring some checks but dishonoring others and was found by the IRS to be a responsible person.
  2. A volunteer member of a charitable organization’s board of trustees had knowledge of the organization’s tax delinquency and authority to decide whether to pay the taxes. The individual was determined to be a responsible person by the IRS.
  3. The president of a day care center’s board of directors, who wasn’t paid for his work and wasn’t involved in day-to-day operations, was held to be a responsible person because he secured loans for the center, directed its tax payments, and reviewed its financial reports. Therefore, he was found to be sufficiently involved in the center’s financial affairs to make him a responsible person.
  4. The executor of a decedent’s estate was found to be a responsible person when the operators of an inn (which was an asset of the estate) failed to remit withheld federal taxes.

More Real-Life Horror Stories

CEO and CFO Were Responsible Persons. A corporation’s newly hired CFO became aware that the company was several years behind on its payroll taxes and notified the company’s CEO of the situation. The CFO and CEO then informed the company’s board of directors. Although the company apparently had sufficient funds, the taxes weren’t paid. After the CFO and CEO were both fired, the IRS assessed the 100% penalty against them both for withheld but unpaid taxes accrued during their tenures.

The First Circuit Court of Appeals upheld an earlier district court ruling that the two officers were responsible persons who acted willfully by paying other expenses instead of the federal tax liabilities. Therefore, they were both personally liable for the 100% penalty. (Schiffmann, 117 AFTR 2d 2016-386 1st Circuit, 2016)

Vice President and Co-Owner Was Responsible Person. A 40% stockholder and vice president of a corporation had an agreement with the 40% owner and president that the VP wouldn’t exercise independent authority over the corporation’s finances. The VP was responsible for running the shop and field operations but had check-signing authority only if the president was out of the office or unavailable.

However, the VP typically signed the field workers’ payroll checks and on one occasion signed the corporation’s federal payroll tax report. The VP also signed an IRS form stating that he was aware of an unpaid liability for withheld federal employment taxes.

Despite the VP’s argument that he had no real control over corporate finances and that he didn’t focus on day-to-day administrative responsibilities, the Federal Court of Claims concluded that he had the authority and responsibility to oversee the company’s financial obligations. Therefore, he was found to be a responsible person and was personally on the hook for the 100% penalty. (Waterhouse, 116 AFTR 2d 2015-5080 Court of Federal Claims, 2015)

Conclusion

If you can be held personally liable for failure to remit withheld employment taxes — whether or not you’re an owner or officer of the company — make sure that Uncle Sam is paid in a timely fashion. And keep in mind that in some cases, the IRS can go after several people.

If you’re tagged, you may ultimately prove that you aren’t a responsible person, but that could be expensive. Consult with your tax advisor about what records you should be keeping to avoid exposure to this expensive penalty.

Not Paying Over Employment Taxes Can Even Lead to Prison

In one 2016 case, the president of a construction company was sentenced to 18 months in prison for employment tax fraud and ordered to pay restitution to the IRS in the amount of $677,350, according to the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ).

The 52-year-old man failed to collect, account for and pay over employment taxes to the IRS. The DOJ stated in a press release that he “chose to withhold employment tax from his employees, and use those funds for his personal benefit, inflicting substantial harm on the U.S. Treasury and gaining a competitive advantage over his law-abiding competitors.”

Unlock the potential of
your business

Let’s Connect

Frisco Office

Fort Worth Office